Workers’ comp premium is your payroll divided by 100, times the rate for each job class. So the definition of “payroll” decides the bill — and at the year-end audit, it decides whether you get money back or owe more. The definition isn’t your W-2 box 1 total. It’s set by the rating bureau’s manual: NCCI’s Basic Manual in most states, and their own manuals in independent-bureau states such as California, Delaware, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota and Wisconsin.

Included and Excluded Pay at a Glance

Type of payCounts toward premium?
Wages, salaries, commissions, drawsYes
Bonuses, profit-sharing, incentive and piecework payYes
Overtime — straight-time portionYes
Overtime — premium portion (the extra half or extra time)No, if your records show it separately — except in Delaware, Pennsylvania and Nevada
Holiday, vacation and sick payYes (sick pay from a third-party administrator is excluded)
Tips customers choose to leaveNo in most states — but see the state exceptions below
Automatic service charges added to billsYes
Employee 401(k) deferrals and Section 125 salary reductionsYes (California excludes Section 125 reductions other than for pension or deferred compensation)
Employer contributions to retirement, health, HSA and FSA plansNo
Employer-paid group insurance premiumsNo
Stock bonuses and equity compensation at vestingYes
Severance or dismissal payNo, except pay for time worked or accrued vacation (Nevada includes it)
Documented business expense reimbursementsNo
Undocumented per diem or flat allowancesOnly a limited amount is excluded (North Carolina’s NCCI-based manual excludes up to $75 a day for overnight travel)
Meals and lodging provided as part of payYes (California generally excludes them)
Personal use of a company carNo; a cash auto allowance usually counts
Prevailing-wage (Davis-Bacon) payYes; fringe benefits paid to a third party are generally excluded
Employee discounts, uniform allowances, military duty payNo

General NCCI-style rules. Your policy’s state manual controls, and some classifications have their own payroll wording.

Overtime: The Exclusion Most Employers Miss

In most states only the straight-time part of overtime counts. For time-and-a-half, one-third of the overtime pay is excluded; for double time, one-half. The catch is documentation: the auditor needs payroll records that show overtime hours and pay separately for each employee, or the whole amount is charged.

ExampleAmount
Regular rate$24.00 an hour
Overtime worked in the year200 hours at $36.00 = $7,200
Premium portion excluded (one-third)$2,400
Overtime that counts as payroll$4,800
Premium saved at a $6.00 rate$2,400 ÷ 100 × $6.00 = $144 for one employee

Across a crew that works steady overtime, that adds up quickly — which is why the premium audit guide lists unseparated overtime as one of the most expensive audit mistakes.

State Exceptions Worth Knowing

StateHow it differs
PennsylvaniaNo overtime exclusion — all overtime pay counts. Tips are included up to the federal minimum wage.
DelawareSame as Pennsylvania: no overtime exclusion, and tips counted up to the federal minimum wage.
NevadaNo exclusion for overtime, tips, gratuities or severance — but a per-employee payroll cap (below).
New JerseyGratuities are included unless a classification says otherwise; payments for unused sick or personal days at termination or retirement are excluded; all Davis-Bacon fringe benefits are excluded.
CaliforniaEmployee Section 125 reductions excluded (except pension or deferred compensation); meals and lodging excluded except in certain classes or when given instead of wages; prevailing-wage vacation and holiday fringes included even when paid to a third party.
TexasSafety awards paid under a written safety program are excluded. Texas adopted NCCI’s 2024 clarifications on stock pay, deferred compensation and retroactive wages.
WashingtonPremium is charged per hour worked, not on payroll, and employees pay roughly a quarter of it through payroll deductions.

Sources: ICW Group premium audit payroll reporting instructions; NCCI Basic Manual Rule 2 (as adopted in North Carolina); Texas Mutual on TDI’s 2024 payroll rule changes.

Is There a Maximum Payroll per Employee?

For ordinary employees, almost never. In nearly every state, every dollar of an employee’s includable pay counts, whether they earn $30,000 or $300,000. The exceptions are narrow:

  • Owners, officers, partners and LLC members. Their payroll is bounded by state minimums and maximums, or set at a flat amount — see owner and officer payroll limits by state.
  • Nevada. Nevada capped premium payroll at $36,000 per employee per year for decades. Senate Bill 317 replaced that for private employers with 12 times the state’s maximum average monthly wage: $98,433.60 per employee for policies effective October 1, 2026, updated each January 1. State and local government employers keep $36,000 unless they opt in, and the officer, LLC manager, sole proprietor and partner rules are unchanged.
  • A few classifications carry their own payroll limitation in the classification wording, and some workers (such as domestic workers in NCCI states) are rated per person rather than on payroll.

A cap is applied per employee across the policy year, after overtime is excluded, so an employee who earns more than the cap stops adding premium once they pass it.

Getting Payroll Right Before the Audit

  1. Set up separate pay codes for overtime premium, tips, reimbursements and severance so each can be shown and excluded.
  2. Keep receipts or mileage logs behind expense reimbursements; undocumented allowances get charged.
  3. Track payroll by class code for employees who split time between jobs, where the state allows division of payroll.
  4. Collect certificates of insurance from every subcontractor, or their pay becomes your payroll at audit.
  5. Compare the auditor’s worksheet to your own totals before you sign.

To see what a payroll change does to the bill, use the workers’ comp calculator; the cost per employee by state table puts typical rates side by side.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does overtime count toward workers' comp payroll?

Only the straight-time portion counts in most states. The premium portion, one-third of time-and-a-half pay or one-half of double-time pay, is excluded when payroll records show it separately. Delaware, Pennsylvania and Nevada do not allow the overtime exclusion.

Are tips included in workers' comp payroll?

Tips that customers choose to leave are excluded in most states, while automatic service charges are included. Delaware and Pennsylvania include tips up to the federal minimum wage, New Jersey includes gratuities unless a classification excludes them, and Nevada does not allow tips to be excluded.

Is there a maximum payroll per employee for workers' comp?

Generally no. In nearly every state all of an employee's includable pay counts. The main exceptions are owners, officers and partners, whose payroll has state minimums and maximums or flat amounts, and Nevada, which caps payroll per employee at $98,433.60 for private employers on policies effective October 1, 2026, up from $36,000.

Do 401(k) contributions count as payroll for workers' comp?

Employee salary deferrals to a 401(k) or Section 125 plan are included in payroll in most states, because they are the employee's wages. Employer contributions to retirement, health, HSA and FSA plans are excluded. California excludes Section 125 reductions other than those for pension or deferred compensation.

Are per diem and expense reimbursements included in workers' comp payroll?

Documented reimbursements for actual business expenses are excluded. Flat allowances without records are only partly excluded; North Carolina's NCCI-based manual excludes up to $75 a day for overnight travel, and anything above that counts as payroll.

This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute insurance, legal or tax advice. Payroll rules are set by each state's rating bureau manual and your policy, and they change; confirm treatment with your carrier or premium auditor.